The Second Disc

Expanded and Remastered Music News

The Trend

with 3 comments

When The Second Disc’s Exile on Main St. poll was posted, I mentioned that I had noticed a rather unusual trend in the purchase of the various deluxe sets that were available.

As a member of the electronics/entertainment staff at a Target store, I was able to track a few of the big sets, some of which were only available through our retailers. Target was the only place to get the bonus disc of the deluxe edition (that is, the Rarities Edition), as well as the fan pack which bundled a t-shirt and guitar pick with the Rarities Edition disc.

From my perspective, we seemed to have the Rarities Edition in the greatest quantity, followed by the regular single-disc remaster, the Deluxe Edition and that fan pack. Such “fan packs” are nothing new to mainstream retailers; recall the crates and shirts that came with The Beatles remasters at Best Buy or the similarly-designed shirt that came with the mostly-Target exclusive Pearl Jam LP Backspacer. But let’s face it: most hardcore music fans and collectors (including, I’d wager, a good chunk of The Second Disc’s readership) see such baubles as exactly that, and only secondary to the promise of new music or vault cuts.

But then I noticed an unusual trend. The fan pack had sold out the quickest – and on top of that, customers were calling and coming in looking for the set. Fellow co-workers in the department noted similar scenarios. Was this how things were going down elsewhere in the country? I thought. Granted, the Target I work at is a fair-sized store housed in a commercial area between several upper-middle-class suburbs in New Jersey. It’s not a major hot spot for music, especially catalogue music (the Garden State has quite a few nice indie retailers for those needs).

And yet, here were average Americans reacting to a catalogue title in a way that they wanted to wear a t-shirt with the record sleeve emblazoned on the front. That’s where the poll came from, and that got me the answer to that burning question: Was this how things were going down elsewhere in the country?

The answer was probably not.

As I type this at 2 p.m. Eastern Standard Time, 38 percent of voters opted for the simple Deluxe Edition (which also sold respectably in our store, despite the seemingly limited quantities). Trips to Target for the Rarities Edition on its own made just 14 percent of the vote (perhaps they too settled for a non-fan pack, since quantities were limited?), and only 9 percent of readers got the fan pack. The Best Buy-exclusive pack, with the interview disc, got the second highest percentage (27 percent) while the super deluxe box (with the LPs, DVD and a book) got only 11 percent of the voters’ share.

What does all this mean? I’m not entirely sure. But I do think it means that somewhere, somehow, someone out there is paying attention to what it takes to sell catalogue titles, whether it’s the promise of extra tracks, a t-shirt or both.

Written by Mike Duquette

May 22, 2010 at 14:10

3 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Since you mentioned that you work at Target–did the Target rarities-only exclusive have the extra tray to store the first disc, for those that already purchased the remastered version from a few months ago? I read it was available, but there is no mention of it on the package. Is there a sku number for it?


    May 22, 2010 at 21:57

  2. The Target here in Venice, FL, still had a T-shirt edition on the shelves as of yesterday afternoon.

    Let’s face it–how many copies of the “Beatles In Mono” box sold simply because EMI was happy to let collectors believe that if they didn’t act quickly, they might not be able to get one? Ever?

    That said, I’m sorry I sold off the two discs from the Jimi Hendrix OOP “Live At Winterland” box–and even sorrier that, after dozens of wearings, the t-shirt that came with the box apparently is gone forever as well. (Or not–perhaps an excavation of the storage containers in my garage is in order!)


    May 23, 2010 at 10:43

  3. I think for a band you love, that’s unlikely to disappoint you, it seems like the “bundle” is the way to go nowadays. You’re already a fan, you’re willing to spend maybe $10 more for the t-shirt, or in the Pearl Jam case – buy the CD *with* the songs that you can play for Rock Band.

    What’s frustrating to me as a consumer & fan is that inevitably there are cases where I miss out on some interesting variations on the bundle or package because of any of the following…
    a) I didn’t know about it
    b) the only place to find out about it was (insert retailer here)’s website – and retailers are not my typical place for finding music release news.
    c) the artist only told their fan club, which I may not necessarily be a member of.
    d) the super-secret edition with 5 bonus tracks was instantly sold out.


    May 23, 2010 at 11:24

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: