The Second Disc

Expanded and Remastered Music News

Review: Pink Floyd, “The Dark Side of the Moon: Immersion Box Set”

with 13 comments

At what point in a super deluxe – or Immersion – box set does the music itself become, if not irrelevant, an afterthought?

It’s hard not to wonder, sifting through the treasure chest – or toy chest, perhaps – that’s the Immersion Box Set of Pink Floyd’s landmark 1973 rock opus The Dark Side of the Moon (EMI 50999 029431 2, 2011).  It’s not hard to imagine many Floyd devotees finding themselves over the rainbow with this package, and of course that famous rainbow is everywhere in this box set.  It’s emblazoned on the glass marbles, housed in a compact pouch; on the Roy Lichtenstein-styled art print; on a lyric booklet; and on a natty black scarf!  That’s not all.  The 29 cm box (which sets it apart from the traditional LP-sized Super Deluxe packages of late) also includes a set of nine coasters, two more books (one of tour photographs and another of credits) and three simple black envelopes of assorted shapes and sizes.  One offers replicas of a concert ticket to February 18’s Rainbow Theatre performance, another contains four “anti-cigarette cards” from a set of 57, and the third offers a print of the handwritten “Questions for Assorted Lunatics.”  For those keeping score, I haven’t even yet mentioned the ostensible raison d’être for this collection of odds and ends: six discs, each illuminating a different aspect of the complete Dark Side mythos.

This set, by its very nature, is designed for those who already know and love the album itself.  For a generation waiting to discover it, comparatively simple one- and two-disc Discovery and Experience Editions are also available.  The band-produced album, with lyrics by bassist/vocalist Roger Waters and music by Waters, vocalist/guitarist David Gilmour, percussionist Nick Mason and keyboardist/vocalist Richard Wright, remains as singular an entity as it was upon its initial release.  Heartbeats, sprinkled dialogue, ringing bells, the clinking of coins, the layers of VCS3 synthesizer lines and roaring guitars add up to a hypnotic barrage of sounds that vie for the listener’s attention.

The six compact discs of the Immersion Box Set are tidily organized.  On the first disc is, of course, the original Dark Side, which needs no introduction.  James Guthrie and Joel Plante have subtly remastered the album which crystallized the ambition and studio prowess of the ever-evolving unit.  Compared to previous albums, Dark Side offered more focused songs, with fewer lengthy psychedelic “trips.”  Its seamless flow of one song into the next, sans any pauses save for the original LP’s side break, is a model of construction and argument for the power of an album as a cohesive single thought, or whole, rather than a mere collection of disparate songs.   (That said, “Money” was extracted to become a Top 20 single.)  The album’s power is heightened by its tight, roughly 43-minute running time.  Whereas so many artists today are unfortunately compelled to fill a CD’s nearly 80-minute capacity, Waters, Gilmour, Wright and Mason had no place for filler in their cerebral vision,.  A lysergic fusion of tape effects and anthemic rock songs, it’s not hard to see why Dark Side of the Moon spellbound so many listeners.  In fact, it remained in the charts for a mind-blowing 741 weeks between 1973 and 1988!  Its human journey, touching on themes of greed, time, mortality and insanity, is still relevant today.  Though the album sometimes sounds as if it’s speaking to a disaffected generation, those themes have continued to resonate on a wider level.

The first verse of joint band composition “Time” could describe the album’s effects on its listeners, with its vocals flowing from pained screams to disaffected acceptance: “Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day/Fritter and waste the hours in an offhand way/Kicking around on a piece of ground in your home town/Waiting for someone or something to show you the way.”  Dark Side of the Moon undoubtedly showed many the way.

To immerse yourself in the other discs, hit the jump!

Disc 2 is dedicated to a live run-through of the entire album from The Empire Pool in Wembley, London, circa November, 1974. Though the band made an effort to replicate the album onstage, complete with sound effects, the performance is far from identical, with differing instrumental excursions and a less precious, more rough-hewn sound appropriate for a live rock band at the height of its powers.  Venetta Fields and Carlena Williams joined the band for the backing vocals.  (The original studio album is available as a stand-alone Discovery Edition disc, and a two-disc Experience Edition also containing this concert as its second disc.)

The original studio recording of Dark Side is presented in multiple mixes over three discs in the Immersion Box.  Disc 3 is an audio DVD containing James Guthrie’s 2003 mix in 5.1 surround (originally created for SACD) in both 448 kbps and 640 kbps quality; the original stereo mix in LPCM stereo; and engineer Alan Parsons’ original 4.0-channel quadraphonic mix in both 448 and 640 kbps.  Disc 5, a Blu-Ray, includes all three mixes in full, superior 96 kHz/24-bit sound.  (Unfortunately the audio DVD’s mixes are not in true advanced resolution but rather inferior Dolby Digital.)  Finally, Disc 6 leads off with Parsons’ original 1972 early mix of the album.

These numerous options truly make for the “Immersion” part of the box.  Each is different enough to make multiple listens warranted.  Whether in Guthrie’s 5.1 or Parsons’ 4.0 (eliminating the front center channel and subwoofer), Dark Side is immeasurably enhanced by the effects that only surround sound can offer.  While the soundstage of Parsons’ mix was more captivating to these ears, the Guthrie mix far from disappoints.  Both expand the stereo soundscape both with ear-opening effects (the cash registers and clinking change of “Money”, the famous heartbeats) and comparatively simple separation of instruments, allowing for each musical contribution to be heard with a revelatory clarity.  From the wails of “The Great Gig in the Sky” to the alternately dreamy and nightmarish lounge of “Us and Them,” each song can be heard anew unfolding around you in a surround setting.  The sound positively washes over you in “Any Colour You Like,” and each color is more vivid than before.  You’ll certainly savor the crystal-clear backing vocals from luminaries Doris Troy and Lesley Duncan, who joined Liza Strike and Barry St. John.  Though the optimal audio experience is the 96/24 Blu-Ray, those solely with DVD capabilities shouldn’t be disappointed.  Dark Side in surround is a sensory assault of the best kind, no mind-altering substances required!

The early Alan Parsons stereo mix on Disc 6 will appeal mostly, of course, to those who know each and every note of the original album.  But for the casual Dark Side fan coming into contact with the disc, there are still pleasures to be found.  Though the structure of the album was already set by the time Parsons created the mix in 1972, opening track “Speak to Me” was not yet in place, so this version of the album begins with “Breathe (In the Air).”  Another shock to the system is the unfinished “The Great Gig in the Sky,” sans Clare Torry’s wordless vocals which eventually won her a songwriting credit for the track.  (In the place of the vocal part, you’ll hear NASA transmissions; one of the song’s earlier permutation sampled Biblical verse.)  Needless to say, the song takes on a wholly different character without Torry’s imitable stylings.  On “Us and Them,” the saxophone and piano seem more prominent, which has the effect of making the song’s quiet/loud dynamics (“up and down,” as the song’s lyrics go) even more startlingly fresh.  There’s not as much “flash” in Parsons’ early mix, as the album isn’t fully developed.  But it’s a fascinating window into the creative process to see what was kept, and what was discarded, in shaping the eventual finished song cycle.

The same goes for the additional tracks that round out Disc 6. Best of all are the two demos.  Richard Wright’s solo piano demo of “Us and Them” is spare and gorgeous, while Waters’ stark 2-1/2 minute demo of “Money” reveals that he already envisioned the finished song, with the cash register sound effects already in place.  A long-coveted track making its official debut here is the instrumental “The Hard Way” from the experimental Household Objects, a shelved album in which the band members would literally play household objects such as mixers, rubber bands and wine glasses.  (Another track, literally entitled “Wine Glasses,” will appear on the upcoming Wish You Were Here expansion.)

The Gilmour/Wright/Mason “Any Colour You Like” is one of only two songs on Dark Side with no Roger Waters involvement (the other is Wright’s “Great Gig”).  It’s heard along with “The Travel Sequence” (which morphed into “On the Run”) and “The Mortality Sequence” (later “The Great Gig in the Sky”) in embryonic versions.  All three come from a June 1972 performance in Brighton; “The Travel Sequence” also appears in a studio take.  “The Mortality Sequence” may be the most striking of these, with its eerie organ chords interspersed with spoken word.

Disc 4, a DVD, offers a dazzling array of video material, which is also presented in upgraded quality on the Blu-Ray.  A relatively brief 25-minute documentary from 2003 joins two performances from the Brighton Dome recorded on June 29, 1972 and sixty minutes of impressionistic “Concert Screen Films” from the British and French tours of 1974 and the North American tour of 1975.  These mini-music videos, some of which are animated, are far from a main attraction, but they certainly are unique time capsules!  There are two audio options for these, too: LPCM Stereo and Dolby Digital (448 kbps) surround on the DVD; LPCM Stereo and 48/24 surround on the Blu-Ray.  The video quality of the recent documentary is sharp, of course; the archival footage shows its age but looks about as good as could possibly be expected.

With a steep price tag and even steeper expectations, the Immersion Box Set can be viewed as an art object as well as a functional box set.  It succeeds more on the former level than on the latter, thanks to the beautiful design of longtime Pink Floyd associate Storm Thorgerson.  The interior is classy, attractive and the physical box is sturdy.  What makes the box cumbersome is the distressing placement of the first four discs, unprotected, on the bottom interior of the box itself.  They’re held in place only via slots with small spindles.  Not only is it too easy for the discs to become loose, but the entire contents of the box must be emptied to access them.  The remaining two discs are housed in simple sleeves, free to fly around the box at will.  (Many have reported scratched discs on arrival, which is far from surprising.)  One might have reasonably expected at least book-style or folder format for the discs in such an altogether lavish set.

Three books are included with the Immersion Box Set: Jill Furmanovsky and Hipgnosis’ Pink Floyd on Tour 1972-1974, a general companion book filled with lyrics, photos and memorabilia, and a smaller book with full credits and track listings.  This is all well and good.  But for all these many pages, the only prose comes from Thorgerson, who reminisces on one page of the main book.  Any liner notes putting the album into historical perspective or offering insight into the vast added content are completely absent.  While the desire to allow the music of the original album to speak for itself is understandable, additional information would have immeasurably enhanced the overall immersive experience.  The lack of liner notes may be the set’s major disappointment.  (An amusing inclusion is a mandated designation on the removable back cover sheet designating the product for “14+,” stating “THIS IS NOT A TOY.  The contents of this box set are collectible products intended only for persons aged 14 years and older.”)

The Dark Side of the Moon: Immersion Box Set marks an auspicious entry in both the “Why Pink Floyd?” campaign and the major labels’ mega-box sweepstakes.  Like the album itself, it’s bold, larger than life, provocative and controversial.  I don’t know about you, but I know where you’ll find me.   I’ll see you on the dark side of the moon.

Written by Joe Marchese

October 6, 2011 at 13:08

Posted in Features, News, Pink Floyd, Reissues

Tagged with

13 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. It should be noted, that in the forthcoming “Wish You Were Here” “Immersion” box, the only live recordings included are embryonic versions(with arrangement & lyrics differences) performed a year before the album’s release. This, and the fact that there’s no “Animals” “Immersion” or “Experience” edition, brings home an unfortunate fact: That Pink Floyd did not allow any professional recording(or even a radio concert) of any show from the 1975 or 1977 tour, an astonishing lapse of judgement considering that the group was at the commercial peak of their career. The “Wish You Were Here” album was performed in its entirety on both tours.

    Phil Cohen

    October 6, 2011 at 14:12

  2. Wonderful review! I didn’t buy this set for all the memorabilia, I bought it just for the 6th disc. When I saw that it included Alan Parson’s mix, I had to have it. It’s wonderful to listen to and point out the differences.

    I don’t know if I’ll get the big sets for WYWH or THE WALL. If a studio recording of “What Shall We Do Now,” is on THE WALL, definitely.

    John Phillips

    October 6, 2011 at 14:25

  3. Although it’s hard to argue with those who are upset by some of this box’s shortcomings (too many toys, the difficulty in accessing the discs, etc…) I’m still overjoyed to have this. Unlike most bands, Pink Floyd has almost never given their fans a glimpse inside of their vaults. Non-LP b-sides, bonus tracks on reissued CDs or boxed sets containing rarities aren’t something the Floyd have done much of. Plus, they must have pretty good security around their vaults as unlike many big acts (Springsteen, The Who…) this stuff hasn’t seen the light of day on bootleg either. So I’m more than happy to deal with the marbles, scarfs and cards if it means I’m going to finally hear the Household Objects material and other rarities. I’m still keeping my fingers crossed that we’ll see Immersion boxes for Animals, Meddle, Atom Heart Mother, The Final Cut and more….


    October 6, 2011 at 15:58

  4. Agreed! I bought the DSotM immersion set, and will buy the sets for WYWH and The Wall. Nick Mason did state in an interview that they will release expanded sets for other albums in ’12 if these first do well enough. Though he did not state which albums nor if these would be Experience or Immersion sets.

    Would LOVE Immersion sets for every album starting with Meddle through Division Bell. The earler stuff…..meh. Hit and miss for me.


    October 6, 2011 at 17:43

    • Nick Mason did state in the UK press that if there was to be any box following The Wall in February 2012 it was likely to be something that covered the first two albums. He indicated that there was a whole host of material that predated their deal with EMI Columbia that had already been earmarked for inclusion. He didn’t seem to hold out much hope for other box sets, presumably due to an absence of bonus material.

      He was asked about Animals and stated that Roger Waters had ambitions to remix the album but that was not on any immediate agenda due to the ongoing Wall tour.

      As for the DSOTM box, it was certainly worth it from my personal perspective for the Live version, Early mix and especially having the 5.1 mix on a format that i could play, never having invested in SACD equipment. The Box and the ancillary contents were underwhelming and I would hope that somewhere down the road, they would release the bonus material in some form that would bring the material within the financial grasp of a greater number of fans.

      Tom Gardner

      October 9, 2011 at 07:25

  5. Excellent review. I agree with your point about the lack of liner notes but otherwise a great set. I wish they would have just put each disc in a hard jewel case that way I can take them out, put them on the shelf with the other cds, and put the box away to keep it pristine. I would trade all the trinkets for another disc of music or video but I’m not complaining. I hope I don’t ever lose my marbles though, I wouldn’t want to end up like Syd.

    I have already preordered the immersion set for WYWH and will do the same with The Wall when the date gets closer. If there are two more albums that deserve immersion sets it would be “Animals” and “Meddle”.

    Bill B

    October 7, 2011 at 08:10

  6. One other thing…. it sure would have been nice if they’d have made part of The Wall immersion set include the bluray debut of the movie “The Wall” but I am sure that would involve a lot of liscensing and legal issues. For the immersion box not to include the movie is a major hole in the “immersion” concept.

    Bill B

    October 7, 2011 at 08:13

  7. The most interesting thing is the 1974 live set. It’s very well recorded and it’s interesting to hear how the band rearranged songs and sonic FX for the live setting. Nice to hear the audience respond to the topic moments of what was already a well-known classic.
    Musically speaking, the main difference with the LP is, obviously, the absence of Gilmour’s multilayered overdubbed guitars, which he made up for with more intricate, elaborated lead guitar parts. Waters’ bass is a lot funkier in the live recording. Listen to Money, it’s a real powerhouse, Waters/Gilmour sound like like Cream’s Jack Bruce/Clapton!!  This version of the song IMO is better than the one on the LP. Same with the Any Colour You Like  jam. And so on.
    The cash/coins effects begin during the last bars of TGGITS, and then segue into Money. Of course they couldn’t manage this with the LP sides, but it’s apparent that this is how it was intended to be.
    Brief, the live disc sports great sound, great performances and a lot of little touches & nice moments which make it a valuable addition; not just a novelty, but definitely worth repeated listenings.

    Audio DVD and BlueRay discs may be of interest for the 5.1 surround sound, but there’s nothing new here as far as music is concerned.

    The rest is all but forgettable. The audio-visual DVD is a joke: there’s a brief promotional documentary taped for the 2003 SACD (which is NOT included); two 1972 live extracts of “Careful” and “Set the controls” which have nothing to do with this set; and the humdrum, repetitious and all in all simply uninteresting tour-screen films (again: nothing to do with the music).

    Disc 6 is not altogether “bad”, still I bet very few will give it a second listen: an early mix not really different from the final one; various, forgettable-  tracks (the Household project; a thin, weak and hesitant “Us and Them” instrumental demo; a “Mortality Sequence” which is not much more than a patchy, uneven bungle of organ and voices, still light years from becoming the gorgeous Great Gig).

    I won’t even mention the addition of marbles, coasters & C.

    My conclusion: the live set (2nd disc) is the only valuable addition which might be worth repeated listenings, in my opinion. This makes the Experience edition worth buying, while the Immersion set seems to me way too expensive, considering what’s being offered…


    October 17, 2011 at 02:04

  8. Dear Joe,

    I truly enjoy your detailed articles/reviews. Can you tell me how I can replace the first three DSOTM cds from the box? They were severely scratched. Ca to NY. I’m sure others have the same problem. How can you protect only two of the four discs? Thanks,
    Richard M Bartley


    November 10, 2011 at 12:07

  9. I meant two of the six discs.


    November 10, 2011 at 12:09

  10. I don’t know what might be Joe’s thoughts on the subject, but when I receive a damage item I ask for a refund or a replacement from the store I bought it from…
    As for storage, there ae some wonderful CD plastic sleeves, you can easily find them on the web, thay cost about $ 0.10 – 0.15 each.


    November 10, 2011 at 18:56


    Blu-ray rips of Oz paired up with The Dark Side of the Moon/Wish You Were Here (96kHz/24bit) audio…

    Above just sounds excellent w/expensive headphones on!


    November 28, 2011 at 23:31

  12. An excellent and thoughtful review that does a great job of detailing the contents and quality of the box – thank you!

    Phil Stiles

    February 22, 2012 at 04:40

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: