The Second Disc

Expanded and Remastered Music News

Review: The Pogues, “The Very Best of The Pogues”

with one comment

The Very Best of The PoguesSince the birth of the greatest hits album, the preparation of such a product has become a bizarre form of performance art. Do you include only hit singles or sprinkle in favorite album cuts? Do you keep things chronological or craft some sort of fancy playlist for maximum listening pleasure? How intricate do you make the packaging – do you need liner  notes, song-by-song credits and all that?

The fires of these debates are further stoked with the release of The Very Best of The Pogues (Shout! Factory 826663-13738), a decent compilation for the iconic Irish band (it seems it’s the only one in print in the U.S. right now) that’s prevented from being truly great by a number of easily preventable factors.

The Very Best of The Pogues certainly doesn’t lack for audio quality. The 18 tracks herein (singles and album cuts alike) are all tastefully mastered by Bob Fisher at Pacific Multimedia, and all of them are great tunes for new Pogues fans to gnaw on. “Dirty Old Town,” “Rain Street,” “The Irish Rover” with The Dubliners, “Fairytale of New York” with Kirsty MacColl, “Tuesday Morning” (the closest thing they had to a U.S. hit) – all of these are appropriately rollicking songs that recall the best of traditional Irish music with a snarling rock edge.

But from there, things get really problematic for the disc. If you like chronological compilations, this isn’t it – and that wouldn’t be a major issue, if only there were some hint as to which songs originate from where. The lack of discographical info in the liner notes (save for a fun but slight two-and-a-half page recollection from band member Spider Stacy) meant every listen had to be punctuated by consulting the disc info on iTunes or my own news post on the disc just to figure out where these tracks figured into The Pogues’ legend.

For instance, you’d never know just from looking at the disc that perennially intoxicated frontman Shane MacGowan was ejected from the band in the early 1990s, with Stacy handling lead vocals duties and the entire band pitching in to write. The Very Best of The Pogues is only one of two compilations (the other being the U.K. The Ultimate Collection (2005)) that even uses a song from that era; it in fact uses two: “Tuesday Morning” and heartfelt closer “Love You Till the End.” There: now I have told you more about the band than this compilation does.

Look, all in all, The Very Best of The Pogues is not a terrible set. It’s been a blast to listen to, and it’s certainly a welcome mat into the greater world of MacGowan and his gleeful band of musical mavericks. But a little bit more elbow grease on the overall presentation could have turned this set from a probable introduction to a more confident one.

Written by Mike Duquette

January 23, 2013 at 10:10

Posted in Compilations, Reviews, The Pogues

Tagged with

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. I can’t really argue with any of the points made in this review, except for a very existentialist one – what’s the point? The Pogues catalog is pretty succinct. Any serious fan will have all the remastered and expanded CDs, which do an excellent job of rounding up their plentiful non-lp sides. Beyond that – for real fanatics – there’s a boxed set of rarities which doesn’t duplicate anything from the expanded CDs, and a handful of songs on the “Straight To Hell” soundtrack. And after that, there are only compilations, unauthorized releases like “Live In Leysin” and reunion shows. I wish it were so easy to collect *all* the crucial stuff by other artists, *without* repetition, fluff and missing bits!

    This CD may not have much in the way of anything extra, but it has what counts – a succinct collection of highlights and great sound. That’s likely all anyone buying it will care about. Frankly, I’d rather have a recollection from a band member than discographical information I can find for free in a matter of seconds on the internet.

    They could have done more, but I doubt 99% of those picking this up will ever even notice.


    January 23, 2013 at 23:24

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: